Source: Guardian
Date: 1 February 2006

DNA damage from eating red meat linked to cancer

  • Harmful compounds raise risk of bowel disease
  • Volunteers fed diet heavy in beef and pork

    Sarah Hall, health correspondent

  • Eating large quantities of red meat can increase your risk of bowel cancer by producing substances in the gut that damage DNA, a study reveals today.

    A comparison of cells from the lining of the colon shows that people who eat a diet high in high red meat have a "significant" increase in levels of DNA damage compared with vegetarians. This damage can increase the risk of developing cancer, say researchers at the Medical Research Council's (MRC) Dunn human nutrition unit in Cambridge.

    The finding follows a major European study last year which indicated that people who eat two portions of red or processed meat a day increase their risk of bowel cancer by 35% compared with those who eat one portion weekly. The research, part funded by the MRC, monitored the diets of nearly half a million men and women in 10 countries over five years.

    The new study, led by Sheila Bingham and published today in the journal Cancer Research, looked for physiological changes that could explain this result. "The question was: what was the reason for this association?" she said. "With this research, we have established a direct link."

    The scientists monitored 21 volunteers, who each undertook three 15-day diets. The first, high-meat, diet featured roast beef sandwiches, minced beef pie, sweet and sour pork and cottage pie; the second, vegetarian, cheese or egg sandwiches, vegetarian and pasta bake, egg and chips, and lentil bake; and the third, meat dishes but higher levels of fibre. Cells from every stool sample were then analysed to check for the presence of any alteration in DNA.

    The researchers found that when the red meat diet was compared with the vegetarian diet, there was a "consistent and significant" increase in DNA damage, while damage was intermediate with the red meat/high fibre diet.

    The damage was specific to substances called N-nitrosocompounds (NOC) found in increased levels in the large bowel of red meat eaters. Some of these compounds are thought to combine with DNA and destabilise it, making it more likely to undergo harmful changes that increase the risk of cancer. Fibre may reduce the risk because it gets rid of damaged cells.

    Scientists welcomed the findings as 80% of bowel cancer is thought to be related to diet and therefore largely preventable. Each year 35,000 people in Britain are diagnosed with bowel cancer, and 16,000 of them die.

    David Shuker, of the Open University, who had previously established a link between NOC derivatives in meat and DNA changes, said: "These combined discoveries have allowed us to link red meat consumption to an increased risk of bowel cancer and may give us some clues about developing a screening test for very early changes related to the disease."

    Colin Blakemore, the MRC's chief executive, said: "Large bowel cancer is the second most common cancer in western countries and nearly 1m cases occur each year worldwide. This latest study, together with the compelling epidemiological evidence published last year, is an important step towards understanding and potentially preventing this common disease."

    Ed Yong, of Cancer Research UK, said the study emphasised the need for a healthy, balanced diet with plenty of fibre, fruit and vegetables and reduced levels of red and processed meat.

    But the Meat and Livestock Commission pointed out that the research assessed people eating 420g (15oz) of red meat a day - over five times more than the average man's quota of 80g (3oz), and over eight times the average woman's intake of 50g. An average fillet steak weighs 140g and an average burger about 100g.

    "The danger is that people will take the message from this that red meat is unsafe," said the commission's spokesman, Guy Attenborough. "But they're talking about giving people the equivalent of two 8oz steaks a day, seven days a week. Anyone whose diet is that unbalanced is going to have problems."

    British Beef
    American Meat
    Colorectal Cancer
    Slaughterhouse: Review
    British Meat: the recipe for BSE
    British Meat: the recipe for cancer
    Red meat: the recipe for breast cancer
    British Meat: the recipe for food poisoning
    British meat crisis: has BSE spread from cattle to sheep?

    R E S O U R C E S

    The ALF FAQ
    Meat and Cancer
    Veal: A Cruel Meal
    Animal Rights FAQ
    The Taste of Depravity
    American Meat and BSE
    Animal Rights Resources
    Bowel Cancer Resources
    When Meat Is Not Murder
    Low IQ Link to Eating Meat
    Meat Is Murder (The Smiths)
    The Post-Darwinian Transition
    The Slaughter of Animals for Food
    British Meat Cancer Education Service
    49 Good Reasons For Being A Vegetarian
    How To Be A Vegetarian In Ten Easy Steps

    British meat: 'try a little tenderness'

    "Because one species is more clever than another, does it give it the right to imprison or torture the less clever species? Does one exceptionally clever individual have a right to exploit the less clever individuals of his own species? To say that he does is to say with the Fascists that the strong have a right to abuse and exploit the weak - might is right, and the strong and ruthless shall inherit the earth."
    Richard Ryder